Here's the picture of the red sheep I found. I read that blue sheep can be turned red during a raid, so I'm starting to think that this was a blue sheep
Minecraft S1 #2 Mining, Mining, MINING! ft. RED SHEEP - YouTube
BrickLink - Part minesheep05 : LEGO Minecraft Sheep, Red - Brick Built [Animal, Land] - BrickLink Reference Catalog
How to Dye a Sheep in Minecraft
red sheep - Galaxy Kids Code Club
Series 2 Red - Sheep Red - Minecraft Chest Series 2 figure
My red sheep looks like a mini figure | Red sheep, Mini figures, Sheep
Red realistic sheep | Nova Skin
Red Sheep Minecraft Caves & Cliffs Action Figure 3" - Axis of Action